The recent visit of US Secretary of State Antony Blinken to Central Asian nations, including Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, has reignited concerns about the growing rivalry between Washington and Beijing in the region. As the world's two largest economies vie for influence, the stability of global governance is at risk.
A stark reminder of the consequences of a power vacuum came during Blinken's visit when a major explosion occurred at a liquified natural gas storage facility in Kazakhstan's largest city, Almaty. The blast, which killed at least 30 people and injured over 100 others, highlights the region's vulnerability to global tensions.
The implications of this rivalry are far-reaching, with Central Asia being a critical hub for energy trade and infrastructure development. The region's five countries – Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan – have traditionally maintained strong ties with both the US and China. However, in recent years, Beijing has been actively courting these nations with investments and diplomatic engagement, sparking concerns about Washington's ability to maintain its influence.
Historically, the US and Soviet Union (now Russia) have vied for control over Central Asia, which was a major hub for the region's cotton and energy resources. The Soviet withdrawal in the early 1990s left the region vulnerable to instability, and the US initially struggled to establish a strong presence. However, in recent years, Washington has increased its engagement with Central Asian nations through initiatives such as the Global Partnership on Security Fund and the Alliance for High-Performance Computing.
Despite these efforts, Beijing's growing influence in the region remains a concern for policymakers and experts alike. China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which aims to create a vast network of trade routes connecting Europe and Asia, has drawn significant investment from Central Asian nations. The BRI also offers Beijing a strategic foothold in the region, allowing it to expand its influence and challenge US dominance.
"We need to recognize that China is not just competing with the US for influence in Central Asia," says Dr. James J. Kehoe, Senior Fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "China's BRI is a systemic attempt to reshape global governance and create a multipolar world order."
The role of international organizations such as the United Nations, the European Union, and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) in managing the rivalry between Washington and Beijing remains unclear. While some nations have expressed interest in strengthening their ties with these organizations, others appear hesitant due to concerns about loss of sovereignty.
Recent developments in the region highlight the risks of a power vacuum. In April 2023, Kyrgyzstan hosted a major security summit involving China, Russia, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan, which was seen as an attempt by Beijing to strengthen its influence in the region. Similarly, in June 2022, Turkmenistan signed a landmark gas deal with China, marking a significant shift towards cooperation between the two nations.
Looking ahead, the next six months will be critical for policymakers seeking to navigate this complex web of alliances and rivalries. Short-term outcomes will depend on the ability of both Washington and Beijing to engage in constructive dialogue and find common ground. However, if tensions escalate, the consequences could be devastating, with regional instability and global security at risk.
In the long term, the future of US-China rivalry in Central Asia will depend on a range of factors, including the trajectory of BRI, the pace of economic development, and the evolving nature of international governance. One thing is certain: policymakers must prioritize engagement and cooperation to prevent a power vacuum that could have far-reaching consequences for global stability.
The implications of this rivalry extend beyond Central Asia, with significant implications for global governance, trade, and security. As nations seek to navigate this complex landscape, it is essential that we engage in informed debate about the risks and opportunities presented by US-China rivalry in the region.
What are your thoughts on the implications of US-China rivalry in Central Asia? Share your insights below.